Contact Us
Switching Web Design Agencies BannerSwitching Web Design Agencies Banner

~ 14 min read

Switching Web Design Agencies: A Practical Guide

By Neil Kilgallon on Tuesday, 17 November 2026

There are several reasons you might consider changing web design agencies. Updates may be taking too long, communication may have become difficult, or your business may need expertise your current agency cannot provide. Sometimes, the relationship has simply reached a point where a different team would be a better fit.

Even when the reasons for moving are clear, it can be hard to know where to start. Your existing agency may manage your hosting, domain and website accounts, leaving you unsure what access you need or how a handover might affect your business. You may also worry about losing search rankings, interrupting enquiries, or having to rebuild a website that still meets your needs.

At ID Studio, we’ve helped businesses move from other agencies by taking over existing websites and managing redesigns and migrations. In this guide, we explain what to check before giving notice, what to request from your current agency and how to choose a new team that can provide the expertise and support you need.

Can You Change Agency Without Rebuilding Your Website?

Often, yes. Changing the team responsible for your website doesn't automatically require a redesign, new hosting, or a different domain. The incoming agency should first review the existing technology, access, licences and documentation to establish what it can support.

At ID Studio, our web development team can assess what to keep and what needs attention. If the website itself needs changes, our guide to a website refresh, redesign, or rebuild explains your options.

 

Who Owns & Controls Your Website?

Start by separating ownership, licensed use and account access. Your contract should explain which design and code assets belong to your business, which third-party licences apply, and what you can hand over. Check who is recorded as the domain registrant, who controls renewals and DNS, and whether your business can access the account independently of its agency.

​Use the checklist below to confirm what can be handed over and who will provide access. Also inventory Search Console, Tag Manager, DNS and CDN accounts, consent tools, payment services and integration credentials. If DNS changes, preserve the records used for email and its authentication.

AssetWhat To CheckPotential Issues
Domain nameCheck the registered holder, renewal details and access to the registrar and DNS accounts. Confirm any transfer requirements with the registrar; these vary by domain type.If the domain is registered to another party, clarify the transfer arrangements and any agreed charges before giving notice. Check renewal dates and recovery contacts so the domain does not expire during the handover.
HostingWho holds the hosting account, and how can you access the server?Confirm how files, databases and configuration will be transferred if hosting changes. Direct server access isn't always needed: a full export or managed transfer may be enough, depending on the platform.
Website codeClarify with your web agency who owns the code. Does your website use any plugins, themes, or 3rd-party solutions?Check whether custom code can be maintained by another team and whether documentation is available. Review each plugin and theme licence: some agency licences need replacing, and access to updates or support may depend on an active subscription.
Design assetsWho owns the digital assets? This is not just the imagery. This also includes assets such as Figma, Adobe XD, Illustrator, and Photoshop files. Often overlooked is whether fonts are licensed.Confirm which editable design files are included in the handover and whether image and font licences cover continued use by your business. Missing source files can make later design changes more time-consuming; licences may need to be transferred or replaced.
DatabaseCan the agency supply a complete, usable database export and any keys, configuration or documentation needed to restore it?An incomplete export or missing encryption keys can prevent restoration. The new agency should test the export securely and confirm it includes the data needed for the handover.
CMS controlRetain suitable administrator access for your business. Give the incoming agency named accounts with the permissions it needs, and review existing users.Remove outgoing access at the agreed handover point. Use individual accounts and multi-factor authentication where available, rather than sharing one administrator login.
GA4Make sure your business has appropriate Administrator access to its GA4 property and can manage access independently of the outgoing agency.Preserve access to the existing reporting history. Check how the property is organised before agreeing a transfer, especially if an agency account contains several clients. Unnecessarily replacing the property creates a separate reporting history.
Site backupsKeep a complete backup in storage your business controls, with access for authorised people. Protect it securely and retain any decryption keys needed to restore it.A backup is only useful if you can restore it. Check that it includes the necessary files, database, uploads and configuration, and test restoration before the existing service ends

 

‘Changing web agencies is much easier when you own and control the key assets that make up your website. A good web agency should be a strategic partner, helping to make your website stronger and more effective without taking away your control or making your business unnecessarily dependent on them.’

Neil Kilgallon, Digital Marketing Director, ID Studio

page_images.png

Reasons Businesses Have Moved

A change of agency can follow a merger, a shift in business priorities or the retirement of an existing supplier. It can also reflect a gap between the service you need and the support currently available.

​Common reasons for moving include changing technical requirements, leadership changes, slow delivery, and cost concerns.

  1. Changing requirements: Your website may need new integrations, more flexible content management or support for a rebrand. Check whether the existing team can deliver that work and explain the available options. A move may be appropriate when your requirements extend beyond its expertise.
  2. Leadership changes: A new management team may review its suppliers or bring in an agency it has worked with before. A clear handover still matters, even if the previous relationship was positive.
  3. Slow delivery or communication: Repeated delays, unclear responsibilities or difficulty getting help can make everyday website management harder. Agree what needs to improve and whether the current agency can meet those expectations.
  4. Costs and value: Compare what the agreement includes, how additional work is approved and what happens to unused hours. Our guide to why website costs vary between agencies explains how scope differences affect pricing. Common concerns include:
  5. A business needs to cut costs and reduce its marketing expenditure.
  6. When a client does not feel they are getting value for money.
  7. The support allowance isn't being used as expected, or the agreement's carry-over terms don't suit the business.
  8. Additional work, software or licence costs are unclear or are not being agreed in advance.

What Needs Managing Before Switching?

Once access and responsibilities are clear, agree exactly what is changing. An agency handover may involve only access and support arrangements, or it may include hosting, development, or a domain migration. At ID Studio, we review those requirements before setting the scope, timings and launch checks.

​Below are some of the core processes we support.

Strategic Plan

Agree the notice period, handover dates, responsible people and approval points before work begins. If the move includes a redesign or new functionality, preparing a website brief helps both teams work from the same requirements.

StepProcessImportance
One point of contactAppoint one person to work with the web agencies; they will be the communication channel and approve stages.One person should collect feedback from the relevant teams, resolve conflicting requests and confirm decisions. This helps prevent delays and contradictory instructions.
Business objectivesCreate a report outlining the reasons for the move, critical outcomes, and key deadlines.This document can be referred to during the transition. It also helps to keep the project focused and aligned with business needs.
OwnershipClearly define who is responsible for specific areas of the move.Helps to reduce confusion and ensure tasks are completed. It also improves communication, as people know who to contact with questions or issues.
Inform relevant stakeholdersInform parties that might be affected by the move, this is internal and external.Helps prepare people for any potential disruption or confusion from changes.

Website Audit

Review the existing website before agreeing to the handover. A crawler such as Screaming Frog can identify accessible pages, metadata, links, and redirects, but you should check it against sitemaps, Search Console, analytics, and the CMS so you don't miss important content. Our guide to performing a website audit explains the broader review.

Audit ItemReason
Complete site inventory audit (URLs, subdomains, landing pages, databases, PDFs, etc.)Ensures nothing is missed during the move and gives the new agency a clear overview. In our experience, many businesses also find missing areas on their website and old content that is no longer relevant.

Comprehensive Backup

Ask the existing agency to supply the files, database and configuration needed to restore the website. Record external dependencies separately: a website backup does not include the accounts or data held by services such as payment providers.

Audit ItemReason
Keep secure copies of the website files, database, uploads and configuration in separate locations. Retain any required encryption keys and test restoration in a restricted environment, with appropriate protection for personal data.A tested backup provides a recovery point if the transfer fails. Agree when the final backup will be taken and how any enquiries, orders or content changes received afterwards will be preserved.

Website Metrics

Record a reporting baseline before changes begin. Review a recent period and, where available, the same period in the previous year so seasonal changes are easier to recognise. Keep access to the existing GA4 property and Search Console data, and note which enquiries or transactions are being measured.

  • Search/Analytics
    • Search engine rankings for targeted keywords
    • Organic sessions, enquiries or other key events in GA4; clicks and impressions in Search Console
    • Backlink profile
    • AI visibility
  • Technical Review
    • Live URLs
    • Status of 404s, 301s, etc
    • Duplicate titles, duplicate/near-duplicate content
    • Record all structured data currently implemented
    • Website uptime

Questions To Ask Your Existing Agency

Ask your current agency to confirm the notice period, handover deliverables and any agreed charges in writing. Give both teams a named contact and a realistic timetable. Clear, professional communication makes it easier to resolve access questions and keep the website supported during the transfer.

Before you finish working with your existing agency, ask:

  1. What notice period do we need to provide?
  2. Is there a cost to provide backup files, or is this included within the existing contract?
  3. Can you provide a list of all plugins, licences and subscriptions?
  4. Are there any custom integrations or third-party services that the new agency needs to know about?
  5. Are there any technical issues we need to be aware of?
  6. Will you communicate with the new agency, or do we need to be the intermediary?
  7. Will you delete the existing website immediately, or will you keep it for a period of time?
  8. Is there any information the new agency should know to help with the move?

Record the answers in the handover plan, including the dates for transferring access, completing checks and ending the previous service. Your business should retain control of its key accounts while the new agency receives the access it needs.

Choosing An Agency To Take Over Your Website

Our guide to choosing a web design agency covers the wider selection process. For a website takeover, ask how the team will assess the existing site, manage the handover and support it afterwards.

Relevant technical experience: Can the agency maintain your CMS, custom code and integrations? Ask for examples of comparable work and an explanation of any changes it recommends.

A clear handover process: Agree who will coordinate with the outgoing agency, what must be supplied and how the website will be tested. Confirm what you can expect to retain and access if you move again.

A suitable platform: We recommend technology around the work your website needs to do. For Listening Books, this meant bringing fragmented membership and library systems into a Laravel platform and migrating more than one million records. The relevant question is whether the proposed approach fits your requirements and can be maintained over time.

A defined agreement: Check the notice period, support allowance, response arrangements, licence costs and process for approving additional work. Hosting, maintenance and development should each have a clear scope.

‘In many of our initial discovery calls, clients tell us their previous agency didn’t cover things they expected to be part of the project, whether that was SEO, brand strategy, or simply having someone available to answer questions. Being clear about what’s included from the start helps avoid confusion and makes sure everyone knows what to expect.’ Michael Macneil, Creative Director, ID Studio Web Design.

Protecting Your SEO When Switching Agencies

Changing agencies alone does not require changing your URLs or content. Where the move includes a redesign or domain change, plan the SEO work before launch. Temporary ranking fluctuations can still occur as search engines process the changes. Our technical SEO work covers the issues that need attention, while our guide to protecting SEO during a redesign explains the wider process.

What to checkWhy it is important
Complete URL redirect mapKeep useful URLs unchanged where possible. Where they change, map each old page to its closest relevant replacement and test permanent redirects. Avoid sending unrelated pages to the homepage, and retain migration redirects for at least a year.
Record page performancesPrioritise pages that attract relevant organic visits, enquiries or valuable backlinks, alongside content essential to customers. Check these before and after launch.
Record all page metadataRecord titles, descriptions, headings and key content so you can distinguish planned changes from accidental losses. Preserve useful content and review intentional changes against the page's purpose.
Internal linksUpdate internal links to the final page addresses and check canonical tags point to the intended live URLs. Test important journeys and look for broken links or unnecessary redirect chains.
Check robots.txt and XML sitemapsCheck that the live site can be crawled and that indexable pages have no accidental noindex restrictions. Update the sitemap if URLs change. Use Search Console's Change of Address only for an applicable domain or subdomain move.
GA4Keep access to existing GA4 and Search Console reporting. Test consent settings, tracking and key events after the handover so an implementation fault is not mistaken for a traffic decline

Staging Sites

  1. Keep staging behind password protection or equivalent access controls so unfinished content is not publicly accessible. If noindex is used on a publicly accessible test page, search engines must be able to crawl the page to see that instruction. Nofollow is not a substitute for noindex or access protection.
  2. Before launch, check that the live pages are accessible, use the correct canonical URLs and have no accidental staging restrictions. The staging environment should remain protected.

Website Switching Checklist

Use the checklist below to assign responsibilities and record approval. Apply the migration tasks where hosting, URLs, or the website itself are changing; an agency-only handover may need fewer technical steps. Agree on the final backup, any pause in content updates, testing and the point at which the outgoing service can end.

ResponsibilityTask Required
SEO Team
  • Perform a complete website crawl.
  • Website performance audit for the last 12 months (such as traffic, conversions, keywords).
  • Confirm the site structure and URL inventory; map redirects where URLs change.
  • Identify external backlinks; this is especially important for a new domain.
  • Submit the updated XML sitemap.
  • Check website post-launch for errors such as 404s
Web agency
  • Set up staging build with access lockdown.
  • Fully tested backup
  • Test Core Web Vitals
  • Cross-browser functionality
  • Test enquiries, payments, accounts and integrations, including delivery to the receiving systems.
  • If DNS changes, preserve email and authentication records and confirm the website and email still work.
  • Add redirects if required
  • Remove launch holding pages and accidental indexing restrictions; retain protection on staging.
Client
  • Formal notice to the old agency.
  • Confirm ownership of key website assets such as GA4, the domain, etc.
  • Provide access to required third-party applications for the new agency
  • Review website migration plan including areas such as redirects and any page/content changes.
  • Approval of pre-migration website
  • Website testing upon migration

Website Migration Example: Swim Generation

  • Swim Generation approached ID Studio while changing its name from Sports Generation and moving to a new domain. The project combined brand identity work, a website redesign and an SEO migration. Protecting existing search visibility was a central part of the brief.
  • We audited the previous website, mapped important content and URLs, planned redirects, managed the Search Console transition and monitored the site after launch. The redesign also created clearer journeys around swimmer types, programmes and locations.
  • A flexible ProcessWire CMS and reusable page components gave the team a practical way to add locations and programmes. After launch, we continued with SEO and content improvements, reviewing performance separately from the initial migration checks.

The Results

  • Zero downtime recorded
  • No unexpected 404 errors were identified in the post-migration audit.
  • All content and meta information successfully migrated
  • A 20% increase in Semrush Authority Score following the domain migration
  • A 14% increase in organic keyword placements
  • A 350% increase in AI visibility mentions between December 2025 and February 2026
  • The client reported an increase in enquiries following launch.

The relationship continues through SEO work and website maintenance.

Read the Swim Generation website migration case study for more detail. We have also written about our own move from netdreams.co.uk to idstudio.co.uk, including the search considerations behind that decision.

Agree A Recovery Plan Before Launch

  • If the handover includes a technical migration or launch, agree a recovery plan in advance. Confirm who can authorise a rollback, how the previous working version would be restored and which business-critical failures would justify that action.
  • The plan must also protect enquiries, orders and account changes received after launch. Restoring an older database without reconciling those changes could lose new data. Keep the necessary backups, hosting access and previous code available until the agreed checks are complete.
  • A rollback is not the answer to every fault. The team should assess the impact, identify the cause and decide whether a targeted fix or restoration offers the safest recovery. A browser-specific problem can still be serious if it prevents customers from completing an essential task.

Support After The Handover

Agree the ongoing support arrangements before the handover is complete. Someone should be responsible for software updates, security checks, backups, technical problems and planned improvements, with a clear process for reporting issues and approving additional work.

ID Support provides maintenance, technical assistance and agreed design and development time. The scope, monthly allowance, and response arrangements are set out at the start, so you know what is included and how we'll handle larger requests.

For example, our work with Stats Perform continues through ongoing SEO and a Priority ID Support agreement. This keeps the team involved after launch, with maintenance, troubleshooting and future improvements coordinated through Monday.com.

Discuss Your Website Handover With ID Studio

If you’re considering changing web design agencies, ID Studio can review your existing website, discuss the problems you want to resolve and explain the technical, SEO and support work involved in taking it over. Discuss your website handover with our team.

Neil has been a director within a web design agency for over 30 years. His focus now lies in digital marketing and performance strategy, especially search engine optimisation, social media strategy and analytics.